Shudder Renews The Creep Tapes For Season Two

Peachfuzz will be back, as Shudder has renewed The Creep Tapes for a second season. The horror streaming platform announced on Thursday that it has renewed the series continuation of the Creep franchise for a second set of episodes.

The renewal comes after the first season became Shudder’s most-watched show of all-time on AMC+. The new season will run six episodes and premiere on Shudder and AMC+ later in 2025.

Executive producer Mark Duplass, who plays Peachfuzz, said in a statement, “We made the first season of The Creep Tapes completely independently, so we were able to truly and unabashedly get our freak on. The fact that so many of you watched it that Shudder not only asked us for more but asked us to go even further this time around? That’s just… really, really unsettling. And terrifically exciting.”

Co-EP Patrick Brice added, “We are beyond delighted at the opportunity to bring audiences fresh kills from the closet in a second season of The Creep Tapes! For the series to have found such a rabid audience at Shudder is an absolute dream. It seems ridiculous to apply the term ‘labor of love’ to such an insane franchise, but it’s the truth. We can’t wait to dive back in.”

The announcement describes the new season as follows:

Season two will continue to unravel the mind of this secluded serial killer (Duplass) who lures videographers into his world with the promise of a paid job documenting his life. Unfortunately, as the tape rolls, the killer’s questionable intentions surface with his increasingly odd behavior and the victims will learn they may have made a deadly mistake.