wrestling / News

Eric Bischoff Says Battle Royals All Suck, Why the Royal Rumble Is Different

November 20, 2026 | Posted by Andrew Ravens
Eric Bischoff AEW Dynamite 10-28-20, TNA Image Credit: AEW

Eric Bischoff has never been a fan of battle royals, including the ones he produced in WCW. On the latest episode of 83 Weeks, Conrad Thompson looked at the World War III 60-man, three-ring battle royal from 1996 and said that everybody loves the idea of a battle royal, but they all kind of suck.

Bischoff agreed, calling them a sign that a writer has run out of ideas. He said the Royal Rumble works because it’s a real format, and pointed to TNA’s all-cage pay-per-view as an example of spectacle that waters down what makes a gimmick special. You can check out his comments below:

On Why Battle Royals Don’t Work:

“They absolutely all suck. I’m glad you said it first, but I’ll jump on that freaking bandwagon. It sucks because nobody looks good in the process. You see guys or women being showcased in the ring. They’re given short opportunities, three-minute, four-minute, six-minute, sometimes an eight-minute match, whatever. But you’re getting an opportunity on television to showcase your character and what you’re capable of doing in the ring. You don’t get to see that same character in a 60-man, three-ring battle royal, or a super spectacular lucha tag team event where you’ve got 66 people in the ring or whatever it is. What are they doing? They’re walking around looking for a place to squeeze in and create a spot that looks reasonably entertaining on television. The bar is so low when you get to matches like this, in terms of what actually looks good and what’s acceptable, that you’re watching 18 minutes of dreck. You’re watching 18 minutes of garbage to get to a finish that everybody’s looking forward to that’s going to advance a story.

“I threw in the towel on producing this garbage a long time ago. To me, it’s a writer-producer’s version of, ‘Damn, I have no ideas. I can’t come up with anything that really makes sense or feels big enough that the audience is going to buy into it. So let’s just put 66 people in a ring in a cage, and they can bring weapons. Oh my gosh, all weapons!’ No, thank you. That’s how I really feel about battle royals. Instead of watching one ring filled with guys walking around like the Walking Dead until they see an opening to get a spot in, instead of watching 18 minutes of that content, I would just rather watch a regular match.

“We tried. I believe we tried a number of different production techniques, cameras and angles to try to make it feel different. But the technology was pretty limited in terms of what we could really do. A lot of it, you could do, but it didn’t look good. The ref cam is a really cool idea on paper, and maybe the technology now is different, where you can get smaller, more compact equipment that gets a better view and a better lens. But back then, yeah, you could do it, but it was more distracting than it was interesting. So we tried and failed miserably.”

On Why the Royal Rumble Works:

“Conrad, you just hit on something. The Royal Rumble, as you described it, is what I describe as a format. It’s the specific ingredients, just like you’re cooking a complex gourmet dish: certain ingredients, at certain times, at certain temperatures, under certain conditions. Generally speaking, the more complex the recipe, the more fine dining you’re experiencing at the end of it all. A format like the Royal Rumble is exactly that, because it’s specific elements assembled in a certain way that gets you to a certain outcome on the emotional roller coaster that needs to be a pay-per-view or an important show.”

On TNA Lockdown:

“That is the difference between a format and crash TV or spectacle TV. Everything’s a spectacle. All tag team matches, the entire pay-per-view in a cage. That was TNA’s version of something really unique. ‘We’re going to have all of our tag team matches in a cage, or all of our matches in a cage.’ Well, okay, the cage really isn’t that important, is it? How are you going to have every match on the card end up in a cage without diminishing why you’re having a cage in the first place, in terms of its stakes and it becoming a character in the show? If you water all of that down, the cage ultimately doesn’t mean anything.

“A good format with a formula like the Royal Rumble is what has legs. It always works. If you go back and look at a lot of the pay-per-views that have worked, there are a lot of definitive tent poles in their formula. For WrestleMania, for example, WWE did a really great job early on of figuring out how to build that content architecture that supports live events, pay-per-views and television ratings.”

If you use any of the quotes in this article, please credit 83 Weeks with a h/t to 411mania.com for the transcription.