wrestling / Columns

Ask 411 Wrestling: Why Did Dave Bautista Leave WWE in 2014?

November 18, 2026 | Posted by Ryan Byers
Dave Bautista Batista WWE Raw 6-2-14 Image Credit: WWE

Welcome guys, gals, and gender non-binary pals . . . through Hel Stryer and brimstone, it’s Ask 411 Wrestling!

I am your party host, Ryan Byers, and I am here to answer some of your burning inquiries about professional wrestling. If you have one of those queries searing a hole in your brain, feel free to send it along to me at [email protected]. Don’t be shy about shooting those over – the more, the merrier.

Hey, ya wanna banner?

Jon writes in, wearing his fanciest blue trunks:

If Batista had gotten a better reception for winning the 2014 Royal Rumble, do you think he would’ve stayed in the WWE longer than he did, or was his run that year always on limited time?

When Batista signed with WWE in early 2014, it was reported to be a two-year deal, though with the caveat he would have to take time off in the late spring to summer of the first year, because he had already wrapped filming the first Guardians of the Galaxy movie and had commitments to promote it.

That being said, the plan at one time was for him to back after the GOG promo ended, so what happened?

This has been repeated quite a bit over the years, but it is confirmed in the May 12, 2014 Wrestling Observer Newsletter that the original plan for Batista’s return was for him to capitalize on his Royal Rumble win that year by going on to defeat Randy Orton for the world championship at that year’s Wrestlemania. Of course, we all know that the crowd’s intense reaction to Daniel Bryan caused those plans to be changed, with Daniel receiving the championship instead.

There is no indication that Batista had any problem putting over Bryan at Mania, but he became very frustrated with the company’s creative direction afterwards.

Reported in the Observer in 2014 and confirmed by an interview Batista himself did with horror website Daily Dead in 2017, the Animal was annoyed that he and the rest of Evolution worked so hard to put over the Shield only for Rollins, Reigns, and Ambrose to be broken up immediately afterwards.

He was also asked to lose a singles match with Daniel Bryan with the championship on the line at the 2014 Payback pay per view but didn’t care for that idea, not due to any issue with Bryan but due to the belief that he’d already done as well as he could putting the guy over at Wrestlemania with another encounter serving no real purpose.

In a final blow, Batista claims he was “laughed at” when he offered to do a match at Summerslam, thinking it would be great for WWE to feature him at a time when he was in a huge Marvel movie, only for Triple H and Stephanie McMahon to argue that it was a poor idea because they didn’t know if the film would be any good.

All of this contributed to Batista not returning to WWE after the summer of 2014 (well at least not for a few more years). It seems to have had very little to do with crowd reaction, though, and more to do with creative differences.

Brendan always gets a 10% cut:

Which managers do you think made their “clients” look the worst?

I’m thinking Paul Jones and late 90s Teddy Long.

Paul Jones made the Barbarian and Rick Rude look weaker than any other points of their careers. And guys like Ivan Kolloff went there to die.

And Teddy long walking out with some new guy on Nitro always signaled a loss.

The best answer to this one is in the question. It’s Teddy Long during the Monday Night War era of WCW, who had a stable of guys that were enhancement talent before he hooked up with them and continued to be enhancement talent after he hooked up with them.

Craig Pittman, Jim Powers, “Hard Work” Bobby Walker, etc., etc. This was far from a murderer’s row of wrestlers, and I have no idea how putting Long with them was supposed to make them more interesting since it’s not as though they turned their careers around under his tutelage and they barely gave him any mic time to cut promos on their behalf. Plus, because they were all babyfaces, it’s not like Long could cheat to add heat to their matches.

Sonny Onoo is another strong contender, as 95% of the time the only thing he did was accompany Japanese wrestlers to the ring and embody a walking stereotype so that he could remind fans to be xenophobic and boo his charges because they were from another country. Guys like Ultimo Dragon were amazing professional wrestlers, and they didn’t need Sonny Onoo in their corners to get heat, even if they couldn’t speak much English.

(The remaining 5% of Sonny’s career was a weird blip of time where they put him with Psicosis and La Parka, for reasons that were never clear to me.)

Mr. Bryan goes to Washington:

Kane might be running for senate. Now would a stare down with Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman (D), who is actually taller than Jacobs and arguably scarier, do anything to boost either man’s popularity and would it be the funniest thing ever photographed?

Honestly, I could see something like this happening if Kane gets the seat. Fetterman is a fairly independent-minded Democrat, and I could see him trying to reach across the aisle and strike up a good collegial relationship with Jacobs, who as a politician hasn’t shied away from the occasional sly reference to his past in pro wrestling.

Jase wonders about the guys standing outside my shower with knives drawn:

You mentioned in a previous column that you’ve had some “psychos” flip out on you because you had yet to answer their questions. Did you end up writing these morons back, or did you ignore them?

Typically I have tried to calmly engage with them for one or two emails, but if they’re still worked up after that, I let it go. I’ve got too much on my plate to invest a lot of time in people who are going to be unreasonable.

Read the second half of this Night Wolf the Wise question on Ask411+ as part of your $12.99 monthly subscription:

What’s your thoughts on the current PLE structure compared to the PPV’s of the 80’s- 2010’s What do you think should be done to change it?

I don’t watch WWE PLEs for the most part, so I’m probably not the best person to comment on this.

That being said, from the little I’ve seen and what I’ve read, I’d have a hard time stomaching them because they’re loaded down with ads and a ton of filler in between matches. I’ve never been a fan of paying for something and then having it contain commercials. It feels like double dipping.

Otherwise, I don’t have much to offer here. I have heard some people say that they don’t like the fact that they have to have multiple apps to access all the WWE content they want, but that seems like an over-exaggerated, “old man yells at cloud” type comment. It’s 2026. You should be able to track your apps by now.

I try to avoid answering multiple unrelated questions from the same reader in the same column, but, whoops, I accidentally answered this Night Wolf the Wise question as well:

We all know wrestling has survived as long as it has because it evolves with the time. This is a purely hypothetical question for you. If WWE doesn’t use the blueprint that its wrestlers must look like bodybuilders or real life superheroes like it did in the 80’s, how would that change what the wrestling landscape looked like in the 80’s through today?

Were that to happen, I think there’s a really big chance that you miss the 1980s boom period altogether.

The obsession with giant physiques in the 1980s was not confined to professional wrestling. Thanks to guys like Schwarzenegger and Stallone, action movies went in the same direction, and it trickled down to TV with Lou Ferrigno and Mr. T. Heck, even our cartoons were super-jacked in that era. Look at He-Man.

Wrestling fit into the cultural zeitgeist in part because it matched this broader trend.

I suspect that it would have remained popular throughout the country, just as it was popular throughout the country pre-Hogan and pre-WWF bodybuilders but, again, I doubt it would have become as mainstream as it ultimately did.

Then, with no Hulkamania, it’s questionable that you have a Monday Night War and subsequent boom in the 1990s, because that was only kicked off by Hogan’s jump to WCW and eventual heel turn.

There remains the possibility that someone else would have shown up and filled the Hulkster’s void, and that’s one of the reasons I’ve never considered these “what if” questions my favorite. There are so many variables that you can’t really account for them all without writing a full book.

Of course, there’s a flip side to the above as well. If you remove the pressure on wrestlers to look like superheroes at all times, you are likely to greatly reduce the consumption of performance enhancing drugs that ran rampant starting in the 1980s.

If you tamp down on PED usage, you probably also greatly mute the epidemic of early wrestler deaths that came home to roost in the 1990s and 2000s. You wouldn’t completely eliminate it, because recreational drugs also played a role, but mixing them with steroids created a cocktail that was all the more deadly.

I’m a little worried about Josh after he sent in this question:

Who were all the women that The Dudley Boys put through a table?

The subject matter is a bit disturbing, but I decided to take an analytical approach to this one.

Thanks to wrestling database website The Smackdown Hotel, I identified every woman that the Dudley Boys crossed over with on the rosters of ECW, WWE, or TNA.

By my count, there are 109 such women. Of those 109, the Dudleys put 12 of them through tables, which works out to 11%.

Those women, in order, were:

1. Terri Runnels on the January 24, 2000 episode of Monday Night Raw.

2. Barbara “B.B.” Bush on the February 10, 2000 episode of Smackdown, which was actually used to write her off WWF television before she was cut.

3. Mae Young was the next victim, and she actually got it in successive weeks, getting powerbombed through a table in the ring on the March 6, 2000 Raw and then off the stage and through a table on the March 13, 2000 Raw.

4. Trish Stratus at the Backlash 2000 pay per view.

5. Tori at the 2000 installment of the King of the Ring pay per view, which was used to temporarily write her off so that she could get surgery on a torn labrum.

6. Dawn Marie. The Dudleys worked an ECW house show on December 15, 2000 as a favor to the promotion despite being under WWF contract. The evening ended with Dawn going through some furniture.

7. Molly Holly. As part of the angle in which Molly and Spike Dudley were star-crossed lovers, Bubba Ray and D-Von put her through a table (which Spike was laying across in a failed effort to prevent the spot) on the May 28, 2001 ep of Monday Night Raw.

8. Torrie Wilson. I always forget that Stacy Keibler was once the Dudley Boys’ valet. When she was, she feuded with Torrie Wilson, and this wound up with the Duds putting Torrie through a table at Stacy’s direction on the October 8, 2001 Raw.

9. Stacy Keibler. Turnabout is fair play, I guess. On the March 18, 2002 Raw, the Dudleys turned heel on Stacy by putting her through a table after she accidentally cost them a tag team title match against Billy and Chuck.

10. Jazz. The Dudleys were sent to separate brands by the first ever WWE draft, with Bubba being a babyface on Raw. On the May 13, 2002 installment of the show, he and Trish Stratus beat Jazz and Stevie Richards in a mixed tag that culminated in Bubba introducing Jazz to a table.

11. Jackie Moore. There is house footage from a TNA house show of the Dudleys putting Jackie through a table after a confrontation with Beer Money, who she was managing at the time. I was unable to definitively connect it to a specific date but based on the footage it looks like it was in the Manhattan Center, which TNA ran on September 6, 2008. Interestingly, D-Von did the honors of powerbombing Miss Texas through a table rather than Bubba, as was the norm.

12. Dixie Carter. I wrote an entire column about this back when it happened. Needless to say, I wasn’t a fan.

And there you have it. The disturbing history of the Dudley Boys women, and tables.

In case you’re curious, the 97 women who they overlapped with on various promotions’ rosters but never put through a table are: 1. Alicia Fox, 2. Alpha Female, 3. Amber O’Neal, 4. Amy Weber, 5. Becky Lynch, 6. Beulah, 7. Brie Bella, 8. Cameron, 9. Candice Michelle, 10. Carmella, 11. Charlotte, 12. Christy Hemme, 13. Chyna, 14. Debra, 15. Eden Stiles, 16. Emma, 17. Eva Marie, 18. Fabulous Moolah, 19. Hiroko Suzuki, 20. Ivory, 21. Jackie Gayda, 22. Jillian Hall, 23. Jojo Offerman, 24. Joy Giovanni, 25. Kat, 26. Krystal Marshall, 27. Lana, 28. Lauren Jones, 29. Layla El, 30. Lilian Garcia, 31. Linda McMahon, 32. Linda Miles, 33. Luna, 34. Malia Hosaka, 35. Maria, 36. Melina, 37. Michelle McCool, 38. Mickie James, 39. Naomi, 40. Natalya, 41. Nicole Bass, 42. Nidia, 43. Nikki Bella, 44. Paige, 45. Renee Young, 46. Rochelle Loewen, 47. Rosa Mendes, 48. Rue Debona, 49. Ryan Shamrock, 50. Sable, 51. Sara, 52. Sasha Banks, 53. Sharmell, 54. Stephanie McMahon, 55. Summer Rae, 56. Tamina, 57. Vickie Guerrero, 58. Victoria, 59. Elektra, 60. Francine, 61. Missy Hyatt, 62. Tammy Sytch, 63. Woman, 64. Angelina Love, 65. Awesome Kong, 66. Brittany (Santana Garrett), 67. Brooke Hogan, 68. Cookie, 69. Daffney, 70. Hamada, 71. Havok, 72. Ivelisse, 73. Karen Angle, 74. Kay Lee Ray, 75. Lacey Von Erich, 76. Lei’d Tapa, 77. Madison Rayne, 78. Miss Tessmacher, 79. ODB, 80. Raisha Saed, 81. Rebel, 82. Rhaka Khan, 83. Rosita, 84. Roxxi LaVeaux, 85. Sarita, 86. Shelly Martinez, 87. SoCal Val, 88. Sojournor Bolt, 89. Taeler Hendrix, 90. Taryn Terrell, 91. Taylor Wilde, 92. Toxxin, 93. Traci Brooks, 94. Trinity, 95. Velvet Sky, 96. Winter, 97. Gail Kim

That does it for this week. We’ll return in seven-ish days, and, as always, you can contribute your questions by emailing [email protected]. You can also leave questions in the comments below, but please note that I do not monitor the comments as closely as I do the email account, so emailing is the better way to get things answered.