Movies & TV / Reviews

Avatar: Fire and Ash Review

December 19, 2025 | Posted by Jeffrey Harris
Avatar: Fire and Ash Jake flies dragon Image Credit: 20th Century Studios
5
The 411 Rating
Community Grade
12345678910
Your Grade
Loading...
Avatar: Fire and Ash Review  

Directed By: James Cameron
Written By: James Cameron, Rick Jaffa, and Amanda Silver
Runtime: 197 minutes
MPA Rating: Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of violence and action, bloody images, some strong language, thematic elements, and suggestive material

Sam Worthington – Jake Sully
Zoe Saldaña – Neytiri
Stephen Lang – Miles Quaritch
Oona Chaplin – Varang
Sigourney Weaver – Kiri
Britain Dalton – Lo’ak
Kate Winslet – Ronal
Cliff Curtis – Tonowari
Edie Falco – General Ardmore
Trinity Jo-Li Bliss – Tuk
Jack Champion – Spider
Brendan Cowell – Scoresby
Jemaine Clement – Dr. Garvin
Giovanni Ribisi – Selfridge
Joel David Moore – Norm
David Thewlis – Peylak
Jamie Flatters – Neteyam

The Avatar franchise reaches its third installment, with the latest sequel, Avatar: Fire and Ash. Writer and director James Cameron certainly created an epic, vibrant world with Pandora and its multitude of flora and fauna. However, Fire and Ash represents a moment where the franchise creatively runs out of gas. The world and concepts are there, but Cameron keeps running the story on autopilot without truly addressing the bigger picture or resolving any of the major plot threads.

Fire and Ash begins in what appears to be mere moments after the second movie, Avatar: The Way of Water. The Sully family is still emotionally reeling from the loss of Neteyam in the battle of the last movie. Neytiri’s (Saldaña) hatred and anger for the humans grows, resenting the family’s adopted son, Spider (Champion), for Neteyam’s death.

Undeterred by his defeat in the last movie, Quaritch still seeks to capture Jake (Worthington) and bring him back, dead or alive, to his RDA overseers and General Admore (Falco). Selfridge has also returned to Pandora to resume leading RDA’s operations. In the meantime, Kiri continues to struggle to discover the origins of her immaculate birth and her strange connection with Eywa, the spiritual consciousness of Pandora.

Fire and Ash gets its title due to the introduction of a new, more malevolent Na’vi tribe called the Mangkwan, also known as the Ash Tribe. Led by the bloodthirsty Varang, the Mangkwan have rejected Eywa, and now, worship only the power of fire.

As the Mangkwan also target and raid other Na’vi tribes, Quaritch seizes the opportunity to ally with Varang, so they will join forces in exchange for guns, plus some drug-fueled dalliances between Quaritch and Varang.

Meanwhile, Jake and Neytiri’s surviving son, Lo’ak, seeks to help his exiled tulkun buddy, Payakan, who was exiled by the other tulkun for fighting back against the humans and engaging in violence, breaking their sacred laws. However, the RDA continues hunting and butchering the tulkun, as the war reaches a major tipping point.

Jake faces a multi-point conflict, desperate to keep his family safe from the RDA and the Mangkwan. He realizes that the Na’vi must stand together to fight, but he’s reluctant to take up the title of Toruk Makto again, feeling he might become a monster just like Quaritch and the other humans.

Wait a minute; didn’t Jake just say at the end of the last movie that he was done with running away, and he was ready to make a stand? Unfortunately, Fire and Ash wastes a significant amount of time building up Jake to make the same conclusion he already reached at the end of the last movie.

That’s the major problem with Fire and Ash. The movie’s plots are running in circles at this point. Most of the events in Fire and Ash already happened in the first movie or The Way of Water, but simply in slightly different ways. The major final act climax plays out similarly as well, just bigger.

The Way of Water does introduce some new tribes, such as the Wind traders, led by Peylak (Thewlis), but they’re a minor plot element, only there to help move certain events forward. The Mangkwan, as a new group of villains, are interesting on a conceptual level, but they act so stereotypically evil. Varang makes for a one-dimensional antagonist, and the movie wastes paying her off as a strong adversary for Neytiri or Ronal (Winslet).

But what about the grander conflicts, like the war with the humans and the RDA? What about the Earth dying and the RDA’s mission to colonize Pandora? The movie makes little progress in addressing or resolving those conflicts.

Selfridge is back on Pandora, but he’s a minor presence, at best, throughout the film. Instead, Cameron spends more time with Mick Scoresby (Cowell), who miraculously and confusingly survived the final battle in The Way of Water. He’s back and hungry to harvest more tulkun brain fluid.

Ardmore gains slightly more screentime, but even as an antagonist, she lacks sufficient presence or bite to her character. Cameron spends far more time focusing on Quaritch’s burgeoning love life with Varang and Scoresby, who is eager to hunt more tulkun.

What makes Fire and Ash so frustrating is that Cameron spends so much time rehashing character beats and conflicts that were already explored and resolved beforehand. He does not seem interested at all in answering the major questions. Are Earth and humanity doomed? Is peace between humans and Na’vi even possible at this point? What’s the ultimate endgame here? Ardmore announced in the last movie that the Earth is dying and the RDA’s new mission is to make Pandora the new home for humanity.

As a result, Fire and Ash plays less like the third and concluding chapter in a major trilogy and more like a bridge that continues recycling past events and ideas. The movie reaches a conclusion that comes off as befuddling and completely unearned. After watching a movie with a running time greater than that of Titanic, the movie should not leave the audience with a feeling of “That’s it?!.”

Major sections of the narrative run very disjointedly and in a choppy manner. Cameron and his co-writers, Rick Jaffa and Amanda Silver, bloated Fire and Ash with so many characters and subplots that many of them lack sufficient resolutions — even characters who were set up in the last movie.

Fire and Ash basically rips open the narrative tears in the seams that were present in the last movie. Cameron successfully created a beautiful, lush, and amazing sci-fi world that’s teeming with eye-popping visuals and lore. However, he has totally lost the plot at this point, as Fire and Ash looks great, but the plot is moving in an endless circular direction, if not outright stopping dead in its tracks.

Parts of Fire and Ash look visually inconsistent, which was also a noticeable problem in The Way of Water. Certain scenes look overly digitized, smooth, and synthetic. Then other parts look like they were shot in a slower framerate, boasting a more immersive, realistic look and feel. The constant switching back and forth became frustrating, sometimes hurting the sense of immersion, a crucial aspect for an experience such as Avatar.

The artistry and imagination used to create Pandora and its lavish plant and animal life are on full display onscreen, but it’s still confusing why parts of the movie look to be the very peak of CG visual effects artistry. Meanwhile, other scenes resemble the worst parts of watching a movie on the big screen in 4K.

Avatar: Fire and Ash attempts to get away with focusing on the magic, majesty, and awe of Pandora, but Cameron depleted that magic by wasting the goodwill built from the previous two movies, resulting in a messy, repetitive, cinematic experience. It’s utterly confusing how the franchise aims to make at least two more movies out of this mess, when they clearly did not even have three movies’ worth of a well-developed plot to fill.

Where To Watch Avatar: Fire and Ash

Avatar: Fire and Ash opens exclusively in theaters worldwide on December 19. Tickets and showtime details can be found on the movie’s website.

5.0
The final score: review Not So Good
The 411
The Avatar franchise looks stuck in a repetitive cycle where it's simply rehashing familiar ground in Avatar: Fire and Ash. The movie, at times, looks beautiful, vibrant, and epic. However, the story never matches its visual ambition. James Cameron has clearly lost interest in the franchise, and it shows throughout this film. He spends over three hours hitting the same beats and moments he already showcased in the last two films and simply mixes them around. Yet, for the numerous characters and subplots, Fire and Ash refuses to answer the major questions the sequels raise, and ends in the most frustrating way possible. Yes, Pandora and their amazing species all look cool and majestic, but can we get back to the actual story already? Avatar: Fire and Ash represents a point in the franchise where it's merely spinning its wheels and stuck in neutral. If this is the best we can expect from a three-hour-plus sci-fi Avatar epic, it’s disappointing because Cameron appears to have mined all he can from Pandora.
legend